How we score
Every domain starts at 100. We take off a fixed number of points for each real problem we find, and every point lost is listed in your report with the reason.
The rules
- Same records, same score. The score depends only on what your DNS and website show. Check twice and you get the same number.
- We never guess. If a lookup times out or a site blocks our check, we say "couldn't check" and take nothing off.
- Only what applies. A domain that sends no email isn't marked down for mail settings, and a domain with no website isn't marked down for HTTPS.
- Serious problems cap the grade. Some problems matter more than everything else, so a good score elsewhere can't hide them (see below).
- Extra checks show on their own. Blocklists, look-alike domains, nameserver tests and website health appear as their own cards and in "Fix this first". They don't change the score, because results from outside can vary from minute to minute.
Points taken off
| Check | Points |
|---|---|
| Nameservers The domain exists and has nameservers | Problem: −100 · Needs work: −8 fail: the domain doesn't resolve, so nothing works. warn: only one nameserver. |
| Lock-down (no email) A domain with no email says so, so nobody can fake mail from it | Needs work: −20 · Not set up: −5 Only for a domain with no email. Its mail server, SPF and DMARC lines then take nothing off. warn: nothing locked down (−20). info: null MX and SPF -all set but no DMARC reject (−5); nothing once DMARC is at reject. |
| Mail server (MX) Email sent to you has somewhere to go | Problem: −15 |
| Root alias (CNAME) No alias at the root hides your email records | Problem: −15 NSU 2026-11-16 09:53: a root CNAME beside MX/TXT; mail servers that follow it see no MX, SPF or DMARC. |
| SPF Inboxes know who may send as you | Problem: −20 · Needs work: −12 fail: missing, duplicated, over 10 lookups or +all. warn: no ~all/-all, broken include, mail host missing, 9–10 lookups. |
| DMARC Fake email in your name is blocked | Problem: −25 · Needs work: −15 fail: missing or broken. warn: p=none (−15), or enforcing with no report address (−5; nothing for a domain that sends and receives no email). |
| DMARC last step Fakes are refused, not just sent to spam | Not set up: −3 p=quarantine instead of p=reject. |
| MTA-STS Mail to you is delivered encrypted | Not set up: −2 |
| Website address The domain points to a reachable web server | Problem: −15 · Needs work: −8 |
| www address www.yourdomain works too | Needs work: −3 |
| HTTPS The site loads securely | Problem: −15 |
| Domain renewal The domain isn't about to expire | Problem: −25 · Needs work: −8 |
| SSL certificate The certificate isn't about to expire | Problem: −15 · Needs work: −5 |
| Domain status The registry hasn't switched the domain off | Problem: −40 · Needs work: −10 |
| DNSSEC DNSSEC, if on, isn't broken | Problem: −30 DNSSEC off is optional and costs nothing. |
| Certificate lock (CAA) Your next certificate renewal is allowed | Problem: −8 |
DKIM: we can't always see a DKIM key from outside, because custom key names are common. So a key we didn't find costs nothing. Send us a test email to be sure.
Grade caps
- Grade D at best (score at most 64): Anything that stops email or the website working, or lets the domain lapse: no SPF or DMARC, no mail server, the site or its certificate broken, the website pointing to a private address, domain expiring within 14 days, domain on hold, broken DNSSEC. A domain with no website at all loses 15 points but isn't capped: many businesses use a domain for email only.
- Grade C at best (score at most 79): DMARC at p=none: anyone can still send email that looks like it's from you, so the domain can't be graded A or B.
Grades
A: 90–100 · B: 80–89 · C: 65–79 · D: 50–64 · F: 0–49
Big brands
We run the same rules on well-known domains. The biggest tech, shopping and payment brands scored 95 to 100 for their email setup from their public DNS records when we checked in November 2026. A few points come off for MTA-STS or for DMARC at quarantine instead of reject. A perfect score is possible with a standard, complete setup.
Scoring model 2, in use since 13 November 2026. When we change the rules, reports say so and this page shows what changed. DNSFix gives guidance from public records. It can't see inside your mail system and can't guarantee inbox delivery.